Account Login
On ThePornDude Hall-of-Fame
I don't want to give my sister in law a baby
My wifes unmarried sister is 35 years old. She asked me to breed her, she wants a baby before her time runs out. I asked her why me. She said your kids are beautiful, normal and smart that's why. I'm not willing to have a kid outside my marriage, I told her to ask my wife how she felt about it. She already did ask my wife, they both want me to give her a baby. They asked me if I would jerk off in a jar for her at a fertility clinic. I said I thought it was a bad idea. I said I don't think it would be a healthy thing for my kids or our families. My wife disagrees. She want's my gene pool for her sister's kid. I liked my wifes sister until this, now I'm at odds with my wife and her. I had a heated fight with my wife over this, I think their crazy. I still won't do it if she begged me to fuck her. I don't think it's going to be funny when she pops out a kid that looks just like me, how could I ever explain that. I never heard of the same dad for both a wife and her sister. I'm not doing this, it's too fucked up for me. Hows this going to be for a kid growing up in the same area we live in when they ask, who's your daddy, I don't want to be Uncle Daddy.
It’s time to put out.
Go on man get your cock right up her tight pussy and fill her full of your love juice and hope that its takes more then one go to get her up the dull . Good luck and good fucking .
Actually, you should consider this a great honor! And it is no different than if you got divorced and remarried and had kids with a second wife. In this case she is your wife's sister.
I fathered two children with each of my two step-daughters, and I was honored to be chosen. My wife knows nothing about the arrangement though. Just the three of us. And it was a lot of fun!
Tell your wife and sis-in-law you will do it, but it has to be the old fashioned way. No paper cups or glass jars and test tubes. And once you start you keep doing it until she catches.
Enjoy yourself, and may your tribe increase!
You're an idiot. Your sister-in-law and wife don't want some anonymous donor. They've gifted you with their love and respect and asked you to help. You've spit on them.
You should be ashamed. Man up.
Well, as much as this touches my kink....
You don't have to do what goes against who you are.
Actually, doing what you want will enhance you in their eyes as a man with good genes, and integrity. They might increase the pressure, the more you say no.
If they can't deal with that, Fuck 'em.... wait ... i mean....
So, all of that advice below is HORRIBLE! If you are uncomfortable with it, you are uncomfortable with it. I would sit down and talk to your wife about why you can't do it, emphasizing that you love her and care about her sister but it makes you too uncomfortable. If she still doesn't understand, I would get a neutral party to come in and talk to both of you so you can resolve it, maybe a counselor?
In the end, it is your decision. Marriage is about sacrifice, but this is ridiculous and it's not like your wife's sister can't get a different sperm donor. I agree that it would be way too weird for her to have a child with you.
Do it it will help everyone. And dont cum in a jar just fack her
Go on man stick it up her and pump her full of cum if your not able give me her address and I will give her a good fucking .
No I think she probably wants someone with more than one brain cell, which of course lets you out, as any of use women would.
Go for ur sis in law if ur wife is willing take the opportunity before it expires :)