Account Login
On ThePornDude Hall-of-Fame
Church Wife's husband wants some payback
My wife and I unwittingly ran into another couple from our church at a swap party last year, which I posted about previously. My wife and the other hubby had sex, but me and the other wife did not, at least then. She told me before she left that she wanted to, and I was definitely interested. My wife said that sex with the other hubby wasn't really that great, but she'd be willing to let him fuck her again if it meant that I could fuck his wife. The two girls went out for coffee to arrange something, but the other wife said her hubby didn't want to pursue anything else for fear of making things awkward at church. She said she really wanted to get together with me though. Her husband travels for work fairly often, so my wife suggested that we set something up for when he was gone. The other wife asked if she was sure she would be okay with that, and my wife said of course she was.
Fast forward a few weeks, and the three of us got together. We all got in bed and I took turns with each girl, and they even played with each other for a bit, before my wife got up and took a seat to watch me and the other wife consummate our little tryst. Since then, we've gotten together another four or five times when her hubby has been away.
Recently, the other wife told me that the sex parry had come up in conversation and she admitted to her husband that we had been getting together while he was out on travel. While, he wasn't thrilled at the secrecy, he said he knew that she had wanted to have sex with me since the party. However, since I'd been able to enjoy her several times while he got nothing, he wanted payback in the form of an entire night alone with my wife. My wife isn't thrilled at the idea because their one connection wasn't very good, but she said she would do it if I wanted her to. I'd love to keep having the other wife as an occasional tryst, but I'm torn on whether to subject my wife to the other husband and his very mechanical and uninspiring techniques.
I understand where you are at. If it was me I would let my wife make the decision if she wanted another night with him. I know it would be hard to give up the other women, but your wife's feeling should come first. She could talk the the other wife and see if she wants to still get together with both of you when her husband is gone without telling him. Again her decision. Good luck.
So to update, my wife and the other wife chatted over coffee and decided that they wanted to continue the relationship. She gave my wife some pointers on things to get her husband more turned on and active, and my wife was willing to do them. We did a full night swap at a hotel about an hour away. Me and the other wife had a wonderful night. My wife said the second round with the other husband was better than the first, but still not as good as she'd hoped for.
I'm definitely leaving it totally up to her. She said she isn't opposed to spending the night with the other hubby -- "It wasn't horrible, it just wasn't very good either. Very mechanical and didn't seem too interested in getting me hot and ready. I can see why she (the other wife) wanted to start swinging!" The other wife is a fun and flirty in bed and is a good fuck, so in a way I'd hate to lose her as an option. Me and the two ladies might need to have a talk to see if we want to keep going or just enjoy what we've had and step away.
This is exactly why I love people that preach about church, God, and decency all the time. Swapping is great, but stop the proselytizing
Go for mutual wife swapping for a whole night. This might be enjoyable!
I have a feeling I'd enjoy it a lot more than my poor wife would!
This is all very hot, but I see your predicament! Maybe suggest you be present when your wife submits to him. And you can sort of coach him along the way. Give him hints about her likes and dislikes. Or all four of you could get together in the same bed, and you could demonstrate what you mean with his wife! My cock is rock hard writing this, by the way! 52, MWM here!!
Me too my wife and I have MWM threesome with guys almost every weekend
You’re a lucky man brother!!